Hmmm...would need to know more about your league first. Keeper or one-year? Are hits a category? PIMs? All those things change a lot. If it's a pure points league, then it's a pretty good deal if you're getting Ovechkin and Carter. If there are more categories, then it's a GREAT deal if you're getting Ovechkin and Carter. I know it hurts to be giving up Sidney, but AO is no slouch either, and Carter is a big upgrade over Versteeg IMO.