The Hemsky side, even though I think Phaneuf is one of the more overrated players in all of fantasy. He just doesn't put up that many points. He's more valuable this year if you're league has hits, however. Nash is rated way higher than Hemsky, but point wise they will be very similar, with Nash having more G and Hemsky more A.
whoever gets hemsky and dion.. hemsky is healthy and he has some young talent around him that are ready to break out.. look for him to play with o'sullivan and have tons of pp time.. hes almost a wash with nash.. dion will be huge this year, hes a top shooting d man who will get plenty of points on pp.. im no leafs fan (van all the way) but i think they will put it together this year especially if kaberle stays and i think he will