Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

ViewSummary |  Expanded
AsThreaded |  Message List
  • Need to cut a keeper...

    aj_ranger by aj_ranger . Mar 26, 2010 2:19 PM . Permalink

    So I need to make a final cut before submitting my 8 keepers, and I was wondering who people would cut from my final 9...

    Dany Heatley
    Alex Burrows
    Marian Gaborik
    Jarome Iginla
    Rene Bourque
    Sergei Gonchar
    Brian Rafalski
    Roberto Luongo
    Pekka Rinne

    Bourque seems the easy call, but he's a pretty solid cross-category guy that's getting top-line time with Iginla - yay/nay?

    • Re: Need to cut a keeper...

      tarrin by tarrin . Mar 26, 2010 7:35 PM . Permalink

      drop rafalski or burrows!

      drop rafalski or burrows!

    • Re: Need to cut a keeper...

      BN by BN . Mar 26, 2010 5:51 PM . Permalink

      I would go Gonchar or Rafalski, depending on your views of each. I like Gonchar to be mor...

      I would go Gonchar or Rafalski, depending on your views of each. I like Gonchar to be more productive, but of course the injury risk is there. Considering the number of young defenseman that seem to be cropping up and producing each year (some earlier than expected e.g. Myers, or even Doughty, who would've thunk he'd be this good this quickly), I think you can afford to cut one of these guys. With only 8 keepers, I would assume (depending on the league depth), that there will be a good number of decent defensemen to draft.

    • Re: Need to cut a keeper...

      Terry by Terry . Mar 26, 2010 2:41 PM . Permalink

      I've gotta agree with Gino there. Cut Rafalski, he's pushing 40. If you really w...

      I've gotta agree with Gino there. Cut Rafalski, he's pushing 40. If you really want him back he'll probably be available in the draft next year.

    • Re: Need to cut a keeper...

      aj_ranger by aj_ranger . Mar 26, 2010 3:07 PM . Permalink

      Thanks for the responses guys, much appreciated. Is anyone concerned about Gonchar possibl...

      Thanks for the responses guys, much appreciated. Is anyone concerned about Gonchar possibly being elsewhere next year? Obviously his value takes a huge hit if he's not with the Pens.

    • Re: Need to cut a keeper...

      Dan T by Dan T . Mar 26, 2010 2:51 PM . Permalink

      I would cut Rafalski, and then maybe try and trade Bourque for a Defensemen next year sinc...

      I would cut Rafalski, and then maybe try and trade Bourque for a Defensemen next year since you only have Gonchar left

      lots of good young defensemen will be successful next season, and Bourque is a great all around player thats only going to get better.

      Please Reply to my Post as well!

    • View More Messages