• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Anthony Anthony Aug 31, 2009 10:06 AM Flag


    I give up: Stamkos, McCabe

    I get: M. Koivu, Zajac

    I think I have the upper hand but I would have to draft a FA defense... however my current D are Chara, Kronwall, and Erhoff.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Thats a really bad trade
      i think you could get alot more then koivu or zajac

    • Why in the world would you make that trade?

      McCabe has had more points in one season as a defenseman than Koivu or Zajac have had as forwards. Now, I realize that McCabe isn't a young guy any more and he's been hurt the last two seasons. However, prior to that, he played at least sixty-nine games in all eleven seasons that he's been in the league.

      And why in the world would you trade away a number one overall pick that had twenty-three and twenty-three in his first year in the league, who is younger than the guys that you're getting, and is on an improving Tampa Bay team?

      My opinion, that is an absolutely horrible trade.

    • YES make the trade !

    • You are getting the better part of the deal. Stamkos might become a good player, but I don't see him becoming an elite player. With Tanguay in the mix with the Lightning, there is only so much offence to go around.

      Also, M. Koivu will become a stud. He proved last year that he is capable of putting up solid numbers on a defensive-minded team. Zajac will continue his rise as well with the Devils. He was on a dangerous line last season and will only continue to get better. McCabe sucks!

      • 1 Reply to The Game
      • well there's no might in stamkos becoming a good player, he is a good player, he had the most goals on the lightning last year after the all star break on a team with lecavalier and st. louis. The reason he didn't do good the first half is b/c there was so much pressure and hype surrounding him and he couldn't take it. So i see him as a 70 point guy this year.

        But so is Koivu, and now he has an offensive minded coach so you could see his numbers spike a little. As for the rest of the trade I would take Zajac over McCabe anyday but it's up to you. I dont think i would take it though because I love Stamkos for some reason :P


Expert Fantasy Advice