Must keeps (based on good value or necessity): Dany Heatley - 3.66 (seriously? LOL... no brainer) Dion Phaneuf - 2.67 Tim Thomas - 8.37 (I don't understand why your goalies are so heavily weighted but you need at least one goalie who'll play well and get 70-odd starts)
Other notables: Cam Ward - 7.14 Ray Whitney - 3.85 Danny Briere - 3.49 (assuming he stays healthy that's good value) Rod Brind'Amour - 2.33
Acceptable: Eric Staal - 4.65 Henrik Sedin - 4.66 Mike Knuble - 3.27 Phil Kessel - 4.29 (assuming he actually signs :S ) Zach Bogosian - 2.97 (I agree he should be good value this year) David Perron - 3.17 Derick Brassard - 4.12
Overpriced: Ales Hemsky - 3.93 Marc-Edouard Vlasic - 3.02 Martin Erat - 2.97 Michal Rozsival - 2.15 Evgeny Artyukhin - 2.11 Matthew Lombardi - 3.28
If there's another GM who's weak in goal I'd keep both goalies and try and trade one for some good value forwards.