• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Brock W Brock W Nov 21, 2008 1:30 PM Flag

    Seabrook or Byfuglien? Carcillo or Hartnell?

    Talking about a keeper league here.

    Centers - Malkin, Jokinen, Pavelski, Cogliano
    Left Wings - Morrow, Cammalleri, Carcillo
    Right Wings - Hossa, Perry, Hemsky, Samuelsson
    Defense - Phaneuf, Green, Visnovsky, McCabe, Seabrook.
    Goalies - Miller, Bryzgalov, Pavelec
    IR - Whitney, Williams

    I'm thinking I may want to drop Seabrook and Carcillo.

    Available left wings - Byfuglien, Hartnell, Burrows, Brunette, Voros, Boedker, Raymond, Brunnstrom

    Available defensemen - Jovanovski, Byfuglien, Enstrom, Letang, O'Brien, Oduya, Mitchell, Edler, Gleason, Sbisa, Vlasic

    So.... I figure if I grab Byfuglien for Seabrook, that gives me a few more points from a d-man, plus I can also play him at left wing once in a while. However, I'd probably lose out on some penalty minutes. But I also like O'Brien, Vlasic and Letang. If you had your choice, based on my current roster, who would you get and why?

    And Carcillo has apparently been told to keep himself out of trouble. However, as far as PIMs go, this year in head to head, I'm 5-1-0. Tied for tops in the league. So, I'm also in a little bit of a spot here as well. I had Hartnell and dropped him for Carcillo earlier in the season, assuming that Carcillo would get me about 250 PIMs. Apparently, that ain't gonna' happen. Of the available left wings, which one do I want, and why?

    Thanks very much.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football