• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Tyler Durden Tyler Durden Nov 16, 2008 1:42 PM Flag

    is this right?

    I get Price, Setoguchi, and Garbovski or either Brad Richards for Datsyuk,Khabibulin, and either Afinogenov or Naslund or Cheechoo or Demitra who wins?

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Unless you're really hurting for goal-tending, there's no way you can make that deal worth it.

      Khabibulin will have a starting job somewhere before the year is over.

      And sure, Guchi is off to a fast start, but do you really think he's gonna' keep it up? That's not something you want to put money on. It's not a safe bet.

      And you want Richards over Grabovski (who the hell is Grabovski anyway?).

      And if you've got a choice, you give the other guy Afinogenov.

      • 1 Reply to Brock W
      • C Pavel Datsyuk (Det - C)
        C Patrice Bergeron (Bos - C)
        LW Simon Gagne (Phi - LW)
        LW Markus Naslund (NYR - LW)
        RW Jonathan Cheechoo (SJ - RW) DTD
        RW Teemu Selanne (Anh - RW)
        D Dion Phaneuf (Cgy - D)
        D Dan Boyle (SJ - D)
        D Tomas Kaberle (Tor - D)
        D Bryan McCabe (Fla - D)
        Util Todd Bertuzzi (Cgy - LW)
        G Cam Ward (Car - G)
        G Nikolai Khabibulin (Chi - G)
        BN Johan Franzen (Det - C,RW)
        BN Maxim Afinogenov (Buf - RW)
        BN Pavol Demitra (Van - C,LW)
        BN Jose Theodore (Was - G)

        well here is my roster, what should i do to win this trade my goalies suck

    • If you need G, then take the deal. Khabi & Huet are going to split the time. Set & Grab will end up with decent #'s at the end of the year. Datsyuk will have a good year again and get rid of Afinogenov (there were rumours about him getting demoted at the beg of season - and he just may). Keep Demitra, he's going to do well in Vancouver (if he remains healthy)

      • 1 Reply to T.O.
      • thats his roster

        C Jeff Carter (Phi - C)
        C Jonathan Toews (Chi - C)
        LW Alex Burrows (Van - LW)
        LW Mason Raymond (Van - LW)
        RW Brad Boyes (StL - RW)
        RW Devin Setoguchi (SJ - RW)
        D Niklas Kronwall (Det - D)
        D Duncan Keith (Chi - D)
        D Daniel Girardi (NYR - D)
        D Ryan Suter (Nsh - D)
        Util Vincent Lecavalier (TB - C)
        G Carey Price (Mon - G)
        G Ilya Bryzgalov (Pho - G)
        BN Brandon Dubinsky (NYR - C)
        BN Nik Antropov (Tor - C,RW)
        BN Mikhail Grabovski (Tor - C)
        BN Brad Richards (Dal - C)

        this is mine
        C Pavel Datsyuk (Det - C)
        C Patrice Bergeron (Bos - C)
        LW Simon Gagne (Phi - LW)
        LW Markus Naslund (NYR - LW)
        RW Jonathan Cheechoo (SJ - RW) DTD
        RW Teemu Selanne (Anh - RW)
        D Dion Phaneuf (Cgy - D)
        D Dan Boyle (SJ - D)
        D Tomas Kaberle (Tor - D)
        D Bryan McCabe (Fla - D)
        Util Todd Bertuzzi (Cgy - LW)
        G Cam Ward (Car - G)
        G Nikolai Khabibulin (Chi - G)
        BN Johan Franzen (Det - C,RW)
        BN Maxim Afinogenov (Buf - RW)
        BN Pavol Demitra (Van - C,LW)
        BN Jose Theodore (Was - G)