• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Brock W Brock W Oct 24, 2008 5:30 PM Flag



    Centers - Malkin, Jokinen, Cogliano
    Left Wings - Morrow, Michalek, Cammalleri, Hartnell, Brunnstrom
    Right Wings - Hossa, Hemsky, Perry
    Defense - Phaneuf, Green, Seabrook, Hainsey
    Goalies - Miller, Bryzgalov, Garon, Gerber
    IR - McCabe, Whitney


    Centers - Malkin, Jokinen, Cogliano
    Left Wings - Heatley, Cammalleri, Carcillo, Brunnstrom
    Right Wings - Hossa, Perry, Erat
    Defense - Phaneuf, Green, Visnovsky
    Goalies - Miller, Bryzgalov, Garon
    IR - McCabe, Whitney

    So, I made a few moves....

    Michalek and Hainsey for Visnovsky

    Morrow, Hemsky, Seabrook and Gerber for Heatley and Erat.

    Dropped Hartnell and got Carcillo.

    Head to head keeper league.

    Whatcha' think?

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • I could be missing something here, but given that you ended up with two fewer players because of the trades, shouldn't you have room for both Carcillo and Hartnell?

    • In H2H i would have kept Hartnell. Carcillo's PIM numbers last year won't carry over and Hartnell has better offensive numbers while still giving 100+ PIMs year in year out. Roto I take Carcillo in hopes I am wrong, but H2H Hartnell wins.

      The move to get Heatley and Erat was genius, but you might have overpaid for Visnovsky.

      Overall, your team looks better, but I would try to replace Carcillo. if Hartnell makes it to FA I would get him back.

      • 1 Reply to Matt W
      • If Yahoo would ever get off their duffs and start giving guys their multi-position eligibility... It's actually not their fault, we're supposed to petition them (I've got e-mails regarding that issue, but anyway...)... I may take that advice. I'd just hate to carry five left wingers. Personally, I think Carcillo is good for 250 PIMs. I mean hell, the guy already got suspended for two games. It is a head to head league though....

        As for free agents that are currently available.... Well, let's go down the guys that are own my watch list, since technically I'll have three open roster spots, although I'll really only have one once Whitney and McCabe come back.

        Ryder (might grab him for a 4th RW), Sundin, Federov (might be good if he gets defense eligibility, but not so much in a keeper league) Brunette (good player, but wouldn't need him), Booth (same as Brunette), O'Brien (good for PIMs, 5th or 6th defenseman), Bernier, Afinogenov, Blake Wheeler, Kris Versteeg, Luca Sbisa, Mikkel Boedker, Tim Gleason, Luke Schenn, T.J. Oshie, Brandon Sutter, Zach Bogosian.... Anyway, that's the good ones and the prospects.


Expert Fantasy Advice