#1 - If you're getting Horcoff and Brown, make the deal. If you're getting Doan, don't. However, if would help if you'd tell us what the rest of your roster looks like. You may need help at one position as opposed to the other which would increase the value of one side of the trade over the other.
#2 - To the person that says Doan will not have a productive year - How is Shane Doan supposed to lose value now that he's going to play with Olli Jokinen? Doan hasn't ever played with anyone worth a crap, and now that he does have someone good, he's going to get worse? Explain to me how that works. Please. I want to hear the genius behind that statement.