• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • John Butler John Butler Jan 31, 2013 9:43 PM Flag

    Bogut or Bargnani?

    I'm torn between the two. I have Bogut currently, and I don't know whether or not to drop him for Bargnani.
    I don't care about particular stats, just overall value in general. Who should I get? I can't drop anyone else at this point: My team is too stacked. Please let me know, thanks!

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • I would hold Bogut, because he is a beast as long as he can stay healthy. The fact that he is playing now is a good start

      can you help with mine "potentially huge trade....."

    • Well, when Bogut is healthy he puts up great numbers. He can score, rebound, block shots prolifically, and get nice assists for a center.... Bargnani is very inconsistent. Even when healthy he has long periods of time where he seems to just give up. I couldn't trade him for other team's worst players earlier this year when he was healthy!
      I think people are over valuing Bargs, by a lot. They remember him in his prime, and just assume that's how he'll play when healthy... Well, to me, when healthy it's a 50/50 shot whether he'll produce or not. But Bogut has always produced when healthy, he just can't seem to stay healthy.
      I like Bogut over Bargs. Especially if you don't care for any particular stats, since Bargs is only valuable if you need 3's from the PF/C position.

      • 1 Reply to CWizzle
      • Hey, thanks for the response.
        But what I was thinking was that Bargnani is awesome if he manages to bounce back to last year's 45 fg%. I think if he doesn't maintain his horrendous 39 fg% this year, he'll be maybe very valuable. The real concern for me with Bogut is his ft%. I never like having someone bring down my ft%. And what do you think will happen to Bargnani's value after a trade?