Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
-
Andre Miller for Elton Brand
My league vetoed it for some reason I and I don't understand why.-
who where you getting ?
who where you getting ?
- View Replies
-
Andre Miller. Not that it matters since it's a nothing for nothing trade.
Andre Miller. Not that it matters since it's a nothing for nothing trade.
-
That is #$%$. that they veto'd this trade. Sure, Elton Brand will get starter's minutes wh...
That is #$%$. that they veto'd this trade. Sure, Elton Brand will get starter's minutes while Dirk is out. But that is only a small portion of the season. Once Dirk gets back Brand will still be in the rotation, but if Dirk and Kaman stay healthy his fantasy value will be limited. But you can't veto a trade on the assumption that somebody else will get hurt, no matter how injury prone they are (Kaman).
Miller is getting old and Lawson will have the majority of the PG minutes, but like last year, they have shown that at times they can both be on the court at the same time. And even in a limited role, Miller could still rack up the assists, especially compared to almost every other backup PG.
So even though Brand might have a good amount more value for a few weeks, and a little bit more value for the whole season, this is NOT a vetoable trade.
It's basically trading an old backup PF/C for an old backup PG.
I would post the link to this thread on the message board of your league, and ask them to respond to these statements against the veto.
A veto should only be used if 1) there is collusion/cheating (two teams working together) or 2) A trade is so lopsided that it will effect the outcome of the entire league (example: Elton Brand for Kevin Durant and Chris Paul). Other than that, let the trades through. There are very very rarely trades that are exactly 50-50. Most trades have a winner and a loser as far as face value goes, but that doesn't mean it should get veto'd. -
Only reason maybe is because Brand will get starters minutes now, but once Dirk is back th...
Only reason maybe is because Brand will get starters minutes now, but once Dirk is back they are both backups at this point in their careers. Brand wasn't horrible last year fantasy wise, just didn't score much. If he can still give 10 and 7 a game that's good quality from a 8th rd+ guy.
-
????????????
????????????
- View Replies
-
Brand will most likely get starters minutes while Miller is going to back up Lawson and is...
Brand will most likely get starters minutes while Miller is going to back up Lawson and is at the end of his career. I'm not saying it should of been vetoed because they are both later round picks, but I can see the argument for why it did.
-
I wouldn't have vetoed, but the aging brand has far more value than the aging miller.
I wouldn't have vetoed, but the aging brand has far more value than the aging miller.
- View Replies
-
I needed a 3rd PG on my team. My other PGs are Dragic & Holiday.
I needed a 3rd PG on my team. My other PGs are Dragic & Holiday.
- View More Messages
-