• Who to Start Message Board

  • Josh B Josh B Nov 15, 2012 10:07 PM Flag

    Huge megatron trade, please help!

    3 versions of a trade were offered to me:
    1) calvin johnson, ponder and 2nd round pick for mcfadden, luck and a 4th round pick
    2) calvin johnson and a 3rd rounder for peyton and a 2nd rounder
    3) calvin, mathews and a 1st rounder for peyton, mcfadden and a 3rd rounder
    it's 12 team ppr league and we keep 5 players (but we can only keep 1 qb)
    I'm currently in 2nd place at 7-3

    My team right now: (we start two qb)
    qb: Matt Ryan
    qb2: Ponder
    wr: Calvin Johnson
    wr: Welker
    rb: Moriss
    rb: Mathews
    te: Gronk
    wr/rb: Colston

    will any of these trades benefit me?

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Dude, the 3rd one for sure. Let's break it down:

      CJ: Madden Curse. It's real, and Titus Young is becoming the new star. Sell high.
      Matthews: So very risky with injuries and Ronnie Brown grabbing TD's and the limelight.

      PEYTON MANNING: Really? Do you need an explanation? Worth more than both of your trades combined. Unless your scoring settings are goofy as hell.

    • NO!!! It ain't broke, so don't try to fix it. If you can only keep one qb, it should without a doubt be Ryan. Plus, Calvin is starting to get hot once again, and we all know what he's capable of.


Expert Fantasy Advice