Who to Start Message Board
I'm offering Mike Vick, James Starks and Percy harvin for Chris Johnson, Alex Smith and AJ Green.
Even though I give up Vick I have Cam Newton on my team too.
Still kinda new at this though. What do the Fantasy Experts think.
I think you come out ahead on this one. I wasn't a Cam Newton believer until recently, and I think Johnson will play better toward the end of the year. Also AJ Green is an upgrade over Harvin. If they accept it, I think it's a win for you.
No way - Chris Johnson ain't doing squat!
Vick and Cam are both injury risks because of their O-line. Starks is good option to keep as well.
My humble opinion, you ain't gaining much and you risking a great backup QB. You should be able to get better for Vick.
I don't like it too much from your end...
Green is a slight upgrade over Harvin
Johnson is a slight upgrade (maybe) over Starks
and Smith is a major downgrade over Vick.
But since you have Newton (who has a bye week coming up btw) it does make a little sense.
If they take it I would make the trade. Vick is an injury risk and the points at the end of the season between him and Newton will be a wash. The upside of Green and Johnson however is better than Harvin and Starks.