• Commissioner Corner Message Board

  • Daniel Daniel Mar 16, 2011 9:42 PM Flag

    Who do I keep?

    We have a 5x5 head to head keeper league allowing 4 keepers, I have Albert Pujols, Troy Tulowitzki, Carl Crawford, Josh Hamilton, Ryan Zimmerman, Ian Kinsler, Buster Posey, and Josh Johnson as potential keepers. Considering that Pujols, Tulowitzki, and Crawford are indeed being kept on my team who should I keep as the 4th and remaining keeper? Go with Hamilton and hope he is healthy, Zimmerman since 3rd base is so weak, Kinsler at 2nd, Posey at Catcher, or take a pitcher in J. Johnson?

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • I wouldn't keep Crawford and go with Zimmerman and Posey. Kinsler is also looking really good this year, but he is a bit of a health issue and 2nd tends to be a deep postion. You would have the 3 weakest positions filled and the top player.

    • Posey or Zimmerman depend on your preference
      personally, I would pick Zimmerman.
      Posey is good, but his floor is unknown.
      Zimmerman is more established.
      Both players have great upside.

    • I agree on your 3 keepers for sure.

      I'd personally take Posey cause a good catcher is the hardest to find of any position year in and year out and he is really young too. But that is just me. Given your choices, hard to lose whoever you choose outside of maybe injury-prone Kinsler who I'd list last.

      I'm in envy of your choices in other words, hah. Good luck.


Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football