• Commissioner Corner Message Board

  • Ryan Ryan Apr 18, 2010 11:29 PM Flag

    Do I Accept This Trade?

    Ok I have a 2 part trade. First I trade morneau and bj upton for miguel cabrera and either chris coghlan or delmon young. Then I trade miguel cabrera lester homer bailey and young/coghlan for braun, billy butler and chad billingsley. I know losing lester will hurt but i think billingsley has the stuff to compensate losing lester. So what do you think.

    20 team h2h dynasty league

    c russel martin
    1b justin morneau
    2b howie kendrick
    3b chase headly
    ss ryan theriot
    if blake dewitt
    lf carlos lee
    cf colby rasmus
    rf justin upton
    of ryan ludwick
    util bj upton
    bn fucodome
    bn jesus montero
    bn alex avila

    sp jon lester
    sp cole hamels
    sp homer bailey
    rp rafael soriano
    rp colby lewis
    rp dustin nippert
    p ryan rowland smith
    p jose mijares
    p c.j. wilson
    bn mike leake
    bn charlie haegar
    bn geo gonzalez

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • So if I got this correct, u r giving up morneau, bj and lester from ur current roster, to get braun, butler n billingsley. Chad is the x factor here, and I have always loved him. If he bounces back, this is easily a great trade for u. Butlers potential, (which he is almost at), is higher BA but otherwise morneau, and bj for braun is no comparison. If your in a std league, even if billingsley doesn't bounce back, this might be a good trade for u. I say do it

    • you should do anything to get miguel cabrera and keep him, He's a monster.

    • if you are giving up Morneau then you shouldn't do the trade! Morneau is going to dominate later one once he gets settled in! The season just started and Morneau hasn't had time to settle into the new ball park and just coming off the injury! So hold off on trading him!


Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football