Commissioner Corner Message Board

Start a New Topic

View: Summary | Expanded
As: Threaded | Message List

trade help

Matt Coates by Matt Coates . Jun 11, 2009 12:17 AM . Permalink

Team A gets: Roy Halladay, Carlos Beltran, Carl Crawford

Team B gets: Dan Haren, Jonathan Papelbon, Bobby Abreu, Nelson Cruz

who wins? by how much? and why?
- 0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
- Reply
- Report Abuse
- Re: trade help
  
  wtk by wtk . Jun 11, 2009 12:34 AM . Permalink
  
  Neither team becomes that much better with trades of this magnitude. Scale it down: Doc f...
  
  Neither team becomes that much better with trades of this magnitude.
  
  Scale it down: Doc for Haren and Abreu. Beltran for Papelbon. Something like that.
  
  I find that trades like these end up being washes, especially with seven fantasy studs switching teams. Personally, whether I was A or B, I would keep my players. If you need to trade that many stars, then you aren't in the top five anyways.
  -wtk
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
- Re: trade help
  
  Eric by Eric . Jun 11, 2009 1:05 AM . Permalink
  
  A cleans up. Paps is the highest-risk guy in the exchange, yet A gets three studs....
  
  A cleans up. Paps is the highest-risk guy in the exchange, yet A gets three studs....
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse