• Commissioner Corner Message Board

  • Kevin S Kevin S Jun 3, 2009 10:04 PM Flag

    Hill or Pedroia

    Before you automatically say pedroia just think about it. I think its a valuable argument that hill is a great 2B. He's doing better than pedroia in RBI HR H and AVG. Pedroia has the batting title from last year but everyone thinks that just because hill popped out of nowhere he will obviously cool off. Pedroia also came out of nowhere 2 years ago when he won the ROTY award. So saying that and disregarding the current 2game slump Hill is in. who would you pick?
    Pedroia or Aaron Hill

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Pedroia because of this... yes Hill did come out of no where... but Pedroia didnt. He went to ASU and went to the national semi finals, went to the Red Sox minor league system (which is very good in developing young players) and took the league by storm. Hill is a good player but sooner or later pitchers will catch on and I dont think he can make the adjustment like Pedroia can... Pedroia will hit for a .320 avg this year... Hill may be lucky to break .300.

    • my opinion. Hill. why? Because he does lead all MLB hitters in Hits.. as of today (not sure of all stats between all 2B but I am sure he leads the MLB).. Hill had a nasty concussion last year so he is coming off a pretty fresh start to baseball.. He will snap out of this funk shortly and it will help the BJs gain some ground in the contending AL East.. ride the wave and pick up Hudson if available on the Wire..

      TAKE HILL !


Expert Fantasy Advice