• Commissioner Corner Message Board

  • doug c doug c May 18, 2008 4:06 AM Flag

    drop sheffield for posada??

    im not weak @ catcher since i already have martin, but will posada be more valuable than sheff, atleast in a trade??

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • personally, I would drop sheffield for a fresh cocktail.....

      I traded posada str8 up for Miguel Cabrera about 5 days before he went on the shelf. The dude I traded him to, dropped him about a 3 days later, lol.
      Yes, cabrera has continued to stink up the joint, but he's simply too good to smell so bad for very much longer.....I don't think I would say the same regarding sheff.
      Dude is about cashed IMHO. And I'm one of those rare weirdo's who actually LIKES Sheff! But, my man is freakin' OLD. ;(

      So ..on topic...... "yes" is my 2 cents. Jorge > Sheff