Commissioner Corner Message Board

Start a New Topic

View: Summary | Expanded
As: Threaded | Message List

Next topic

Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

ScottyGTO by ScottyGTO . Feb 7, 2008 2:45 AM . Permalink

So in the many years of our retainer league...I am retaining A-Rod and Johan Santana. We can have a 3rd...I'm having a tough time deciding between Matt Holliday or Jake Peavy...both are top at their position.

What do you all think? Your help is greatly appreciated.

Thanks.
- 0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
- Reply
- Report Abuse
- Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!
  
  Simsy by Simsy . Feb 7, 2008 8:07 AM . Permalink
  
  Sounds like about a 6 team league. Very challenging!
  
  Sounds like about a 6 team league. Very challenging!
  0 users liked this posts 1 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
- Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!
  
  VeggieHaggis by VeggieHaggis . Feb 7, 2008 4:00 AM . Permalink
  
  tough call.id take matt
  
  tough call.id take matt
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
- Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!
  
  The Real J-Ro by The Real J-Ro . Feb 7, 2008 12:40 PM . Permalink
  
  Seems to me that Peavy is more consistent than Holliday, but really, you can't lose ei...
  
  Seems to me that Peavy is more consistent than Holliday, but really, you can't lose either way you go. I would go with Peavy.
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse
  - View Replies
  - Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!
    
    ScottyGTO by ScottyGTO . Feb 7, 2008 1:36 PM . Permalink
    
    Actually this a 10 team league...I traded for Holliday last year and drafted Peavy in the ...
    
    Actually this a 10 team league...I traded for Holliday last year and drafted Peavy in the 1st Round last year...I've had A-Rod and Santana since year 1 we played...the league is H2H with standard categories for hitting and pitching.
    
    0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
    
    Reply
    
    Report Abuse
    - View Replies
- Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!
  
  Thorin by Thorin . Feb 7, 2008 11:58 AM . Permalink
  
  It may depend on your league type and scoring cats. Roto or H2H and whether the scoring f...
  
  It may depend on your league type and scoring cats. Roto or H2H and whether the scoring favors offence or Pitching in your league?
  0 users liked this posts 0 users disliked this posts
  
  Reply
  
  Report Abuse

Yahoo! Sports

Breaking News Visit Yahoo! News for the latest.

Commissioner Corner Message Board

Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Yahoo! Sports

Commissioner Corner Message Board

Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Re: Tough Time Deciding On 3rd To Retain...HELP PLEASE!

Yahoo! Sports

Also On Yahoo!

Trending Now