Commissioner Corner Message Board

Back To Board
Search
Advanced Search  
  • Subject Message Body
  • Topics Only Topics And Messages
  • Any Date
  • Within the range:
Start a New Topic
View:  Summary |  Expanded
As:  Threaded |  Message List
Previous topic |  Next topic

  • Please Help! Should I Allow This Trade?

    Jason by Jason . Oct 19, 2011 1:36 AM . Permalink
    Jason

    I'm the commish in a 12 team PPR league and this trade was just accepted.

    Team A trades: Ryan Mathews, Steven Jackson, and David Nelson

    Team B trades: Peyton Hills, Pierre Garcon, and 49ers D/ST

    Is this a fair trade that I should allow?

    • ahouse

      Re: Please Help! Should I Allow This Trade?

      ahouse by ahouse . Oct 19, 2011 2:35 AM . Permalink

      Mathews and jackson are moving up nelson seems to be solid, hillis is going down fast wit...

      Mathews and jackson are moving up nelson seems to be solid, hillis is going down fast with a bad schedule, garcon is iffy been lucky lately, and 49ers are only solid player for team b ... i find it unfair ,, no way i trade away mathews, jackson and nelson for hillis garcon and 9ers, no go!

    • Joes Italian

      Re: Please Help! Should I Allow This Trade?

      Joes Italian by Joes Italian . Oct 19, 2011 3:31 AM . Permalink

      n my opinion this is a very un even trade. Team A is giving up way too much, for an under ...

      n my opinion this is a very un even trade. Team A is giving up way too much, for an under performing Hillis and a Team Defense. I really need to see both rosters to fully understand the reasoning for a trade loke this. Is Team A Runningback heavy with lots of depth? Is the the core of this trade Garcon and the 49er Def? Hillis for Matthews? Hardesty is getting more carries than HIllis and Tolbert seems a non- factor in SD.

      • View Replies
      • Jason

        Re: Please Help! Should I Allow This Trade?

        Jason by Jason . Oct 19, 2011 3:39 AM . Permalink

        Here's the Rosters Before the Trade: Team A (1-5 Record): QB: Matt Schaub, Donovan Mc...

        Here's the Rosters Before the Trade:

        Team A (1-5 Record):
        QB: Matt Schaub, Donovan McNabb
        WR: Santonio Holmes, Devin Hester, James Jones, David Nelson, Torrey Smith
        RB: Adrian Peterson, Steven Jackson, Ryan Mathews, Tim Hightower
        TE: Jason Witten
        D/ST: Steelers

        Team B (5-1 Record)
        QB: Aaron Rodgers, Matt Hasslebeck, Kevin Kolb
        WR: Steve Smith(Car.), Anquan Boldin, Pierre Garcon, Robert Meachem,
        RB: Jahvid Best, Peyton Hillis, Felix Jones, Issac Redman
        TE; Jermichael Finley
        D/ST: Packers, 49ers

        PPR League We start 1 QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 D, 1 K

      • Joes Italian

        Re: Please Help! Should I Allow This Trade?

        Joes Italian by Joes Italian . Oct 19, 2011 5:03 AM . Permalink

        Here's the Rosters Before the Trade: Team A (1-5 Record): QB: Matt Schaub, Donovan Mc...

        Here's the Rosters Before the Trade:

        Team A (1-5 Record):
        QB: Matt Schaub, Donovan McNabb
        WR: Santonio Holmes, Devin Hester, James Jones, David Nelson, Torrey Smith
        RB: Adrian Peterson, Steven Jackson, Ryan Mathews, Tim Hightower
        TE: Jason Witten
        D/ST: Steelers

        Team B (5-1 Record)
        QB: Aaron Rodgers, Matt Hasslebeck, Kevin Kolb
        WR: Steve Smith(Car.), Anquan Boldin, Pierre Garcon, Robert Meachem,
        RB: Jahvid Best, Peyton Hillis, Felix Jones, Issac Redman
        TE; Jermichael Finley
        D/ST: Packers, 49ers

        PPR League We start 1 QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 D, 1 K

    • green4915

      Re: Please Help! Should I Allow This Trade?

      green4915 by green4915 . Oct 19, 2011 4:56 AM . Permalink

      What's the issue? I don't see any issue with it.

      What's the issue? I don't see any issue with it.

    • Ross

      Re: Please Help! Should I Allow This Trade?

      Ross by Ross . Oct 19, 2011 2:41 AM . Permalink

      Team A wins hands down. That is a completely one-sided trade

      Team A wins hands down. That is a completely one-sided trade

    • Adam

      Re: Please Help! Should I Allow This Trade?

      Adam by Adam . Oct 19, 2011 2:32 AM . Permalink

      Yeah, chances are, they're up to something. But the fact of the matter is, you can'...

      Yeah, chances are, they're up to something. But the fact of the matter is, you can't know that. I let a trade go through that was Reggie Bush for Terrell Suggs! That's awful! But they were both adults, one kid convinced (to put it mildly) the other that it was a good idea. What can I say about that? Just because you don't like something doesn't mean you should stop other people from doing it. If the 5-1 team wants to get a worse team, God bless. Hopefully, they'll both end up with less than mediocre records and miss the playoffs.

      • View Replies
      • Jason

        Re: Please Help! Should I Allow This Trade?

        Jason by Jason . Oct 19, 2011 2:37 AM . Permalink

        Thanks Adam for all the input. It's actually the 5-1 team that is receiving Mathews...

        Thanks Adam for all the input.

        It's actually the 5-1 team that is receiving Mathews and Jackson. The 1-5 team is the one receiving Hillis side. She basically just lost Felix, Hillis, and potentially Best for a while. That's why it looks they are just stacking the one team for each other.

        She has way better receivers that he could have asked for rather than Garcon.

        Like I said I usually always allow trades, but something just doesn't sit right on this one.

    • View More Messages