• Commissioner Corner Message Board

  • USF BULLS #1 USF BULLS #1 Dec 24, 2007 10:26 AM Flag

    WARNER VS P MANNING POINTS

    WHAT IS THE DEAL??

    MANNING HAD A HIGHER QB RATING FOR HIS GAME BY almost
    20 points higher than k. warner
    and warner gets more fantasy points??????

    just because he had more yards? a second or third tier team will almost always throw the ball more...should peyton be penalized for playing on a decent team? or should he be more aptly judged by his completion % stats , yards, td's/int?

    chet lemon wiil possibly rank above everybody next week if he throws 60 times..!

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Well, when you joined the league I'm sure you had access to your league's scoring settings and were aware that the points were not based on QB rating. This game is NOT about picking who is better overall, this game is about picking who will do a certain thing in a certain situation, a predetermined thing stated in your league's scoring system. If you didn't like it then you should have realized that LONG before the playoffs and stopped playing already.

    • Peyton Manning is a better quarterback, that can't be disputed. I actually thought about this, that they should make another OPTIONAL points category for QB rating and completion percentage. I've seen guys complete less than 50% of their passes that were all long-bombs so they get 300+ yards and a couple TDs. That's not good quarterbacking, that's luck and good receivers. If quarterbacks get judged by their QB rating and completion %, that makes the stats more about how THEY play as opposed to how their RECEIVERS play. Yes?

 

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football