Who to Start Message Board

I have 3 OF slots and 2 Util slots.
I have 7 players in question.
Who do I start?

Ryan Braun (obviously)
Josh Reddick
Hunter Pence
Melky Cabrera
Trevor Plouffe
Bj Upton
Dexter Fowler

I am in a weekly, h2h, 10 team league.

The stats I'm after are:
R, HR, RBI, SB, E, AVG, and OPS

Your responses are much appreciated!