! arencebia is a tier below Montero in anybodys (except your) eyes. if you pitching is that weak then yea the trades acceptable but with johnny you gotta worry about his health and the fact he is in a hitters park.
You really dont think Arencibia is a stud. Look at his minor league stats the guy hit 31 home runs and had an above 300 average. He was an allstar and killed it. hmm you really think montero is better, it seems like he barely plays each season. I dont know if it is injury or what but he has had only two good seasons in like 5 or 6