• Who to Start Message Board

  • Dylan Dylan Feb 11, 2012 11:50 AM Flag

    please help on this trade :)

    my cahill...kimbrel...latos...alexei ramerez

    for his..haren..brandon phillips..and james loney good or bad ???

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • i wouldn't do it, you're giving up a shit ton of k's and saves, and era from the pitchers....brandon phillips is good, loney is ok, but you could probably get as good a player as loney from the waiver wire once the season starts

    • you really should give a bit more info, such as how many teams in the league, what the scoring cats are, and who you have on your roster that youre upgrading with phillips/loney (although i cant ever see loney actually being an upgrade), and especially wether its a keeper league.

      with that said, i do think youre giving up quite a bit of pitching and I would tend to hold onto kimbrel and latos, but its certainly not a bad deal either way, especially if you have a few other solid pitchers on your staff and nobody decent at second base. its definitely a very fair trade both ways, but its very hard to tell wether its actually a GOOD trade for you without knowing who else is on your roster and what the rest of the league info

    • why not...

      Cahill- Ariz should give him more wins. ( late Sp pick in my opinion)
      Kimbrel- BESTRp ( i dont value RP)
      Latos - gonna have huge season with that stacked lineup (late Sp pick in my opinion)
      Alexei- SS in his prime. ( i like others)

      FOR.....if you dont mind giving up 4 for 2

      Haren- top tier SP
      Brandon Phillips - 20/20
      Loney- he is waiver material. not worth a look on any of my teams unless im in a 20 team league.

      Why not...YOUR getting a 20/20 SB and a TOP SP for KIMBREL in my opinion.

 

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football