Nicasio I haven't really paid attention too. He might be your choice, because of matchup, like you said.
Lohse I had for 3 out of his last 6 starts but was wise enough to not start him at Mil. I really need to see another start before I pick him back up.
Volquez vs Tor. WOW! That could be a huge game for Volquez if he can miss bats and not give up gopher balls. If he doesn't miss bats and does give up gopher balls. Well, that's just as a huge a game just on the other side of the spectrum!
Overall I'm going with the Kid or Lohse. Pitching against Tor is too risky for me.