Who to Start Message Board

In this case I would sell Posey. I think they will both have similar #'s, but Posey probably will get you a little better return on a trade.

Posey all the way.

Anyone else?

keeper- I would say do what you can to get both of them

How would your opinions sway if i told you it was a keeper league?

Posey all the way. Being a Giants fan and living near SF I get the privilege of watching him play everyday. He has power to all fields and will also hit for average, plus he has the better lineup around him which means he's going to get plenty of RBI chances.

Posey...he'll provide moderate power but a way higher AVG than Santana.

lol both would be cool. Posey's cool cause he can play 1B on some days and he is an impressive contact hitter who can hold a .300 BA. Santana brings the power though. So it depends on what you need as everyone always says.

BOTH!!!!!!!!!

i would have to say the kid santana