Who to Start Message Board
-
Trade Help, Do I Do This?
OK, I've asked this a few times and people seem to be split right down the middle. Should I do this trade:
I get:
Troy Tulowitzki
James Shields
I give:
Jimmy Rollins
This is my team:
C Bengie Molina
1B Adrian Gonzalez
2B Aaron Hill
3B Kevin Youkilis
SS Jimmy Rollins
OF Adam Jones
OF Vladimir Guerrero
OF Juan Pierre
Util Mike Lowell
Util Luke Scott
BN Magglio Ordonez
BN Jorge Cantu
BN Russell Branyan
SP Johan Santana
SP Josh Beckett
RP Bobby Jenks
RP Brian Fuentes
P Scott Downs
P David Price
BN Rick Porcello
BN Tommy Hanson
DL Edinson Volquez
If I accepted I would probably drop Hanson, maybe Porcello, but most likely Hanson. Also, it's a 12 team H2H league, so having such a nasty staff would be helpful, I don't know if it's worth Rollins though-
I would say no, both Tulo, and rollins have been bad this year, but rollins is on the much better team, and should have a much better year than tulo. If your looking to add SP, I would say drop Mags. and pick up a SP, or you can float one, up too you.
-
i would do it tulo is going to catch fire and shields will help staff. and at worst the two SS will cancel eachother out and then you pick up shields. i would do it in a heart beat. good luck
-
I don't see why you need James Shields or Tulowitski. I would not do this. Jimmy Rollins has definitely gotten off to a very slow start. But I wouldn't lose faith in him. He'll come around. Don't do it.
-
Do not do it. Absolutely not.
- 1 Reply to Mike C
-
goddammit, here come all the people saying not to do it and it's gonna be a tie again
-
Your team looks hitter heavy. By getting another pitcher you can get more strike outs per game between starters.
The shortstops are pretty even but I think you might find a similar type of relief pitcher through free agency.
Just have to take time scrolling through the lists..- 1 Reply to Cesario
-
but we aren't talking about RP, we're talking about SP
-
I would in a second
-
anybody else?
- 1 Reply to D
-
cum on, anybody out there?
-
the more the merrier
-
solid team but i would do it
-
anybody else care to chime in?
- View More Messages
-