Who to Start Message Board

bad deal. Phillips has similar value to Brandon Phillips due to the thinness at 2nd base. Yes Holliday is a little more valuable, but not "adding the league leader in RBI's" more valuable.

shoulda kept burrell
hes on a roll continuing from last year and it will continue
at least 30 hr and 115rbi

If u already have utley then yeah but is your outfield going to be strong enough without Burell?

how does the rest of your outfield look? whether or not you have utley means nothing if he gets injured or hits a slump. do you have another 2b besides phillips and utley? there are more factors than just "look at this trade". just my opinion. Good Luck!!!

Do it gotta sell Burrell high right now cus when he comes back down to earth you will be banging ur head on the wall for not pulling the trigger

no dont do it you're giving up too much. burrell is really hot right now and phillips is gonna heat up

Good Trade...Holliday is just not getting W's but his ERA.K,and WHIP is Off the meter right now....since you have Utley you can afford to give up phillips to bolster your pitching staff...Just remember with burrell...he's hot but he'll cool down. Good job using burrell as trade bait by selling him high!

heck no... not both of those guys for holiday. maybe phillips for holiday because i doubt he'll give you holiday for burrell straight up.

whoever's getting phillips is probably getting a HUGE improvement over their current 2Bman. by the end of the year, philips will have 30 HRs and 30 SBs. In fact, I wouldn't make the trade. Find yourself a free agent OFer and keep racking up points dude.

not a good trade cuz burrell is on a roll and is T2 for homeruns not only in the NL but MLB as well and holiday isnt that great so far. plus, phillips is ok this year. i would have kept for sure burrell and maybe kept phillips 2.

Not really. Holliday has'nt been as good as he was. Pat Burrel is just too good to trade.