Who to Start Message Board

What if the trade were Jeter and Putz for Rollins instead of Jeter and Jenks for Rollins? Make any difference?

To be honest, I don't really have a preference. It's all about fielding the best possible team. I agree that Jeter has very solid and usually dependable numbers year in/year out compared to Rollins. The addition of Jenks makes it look that much better on paper, but like you said it is just paper. I think Rollins has the potential to put back-to-back awesome yeras together, but that's a guess. On the second trade Peavy's numbers are slightly better, but neither has really peaked. I guess it's tougher when you swapping aces. I think Verlander has better potential, but it may be another 2-3 years before he peaks, while I feel Peavy's season could be now. I'm thinking I might just take both trades and see what happens.