95% Schnieder, but it depends who else you have in net I guess.
Schnieder is better, and is on a better team...but if you struggle to hit the minimum starts each week he won't do you much good. No matter who becomes 'the guy' in Van, it'll still be a Halak/Elliot type timeshare where the 'backup' gets every back to back, plus other starts here and there.