General Message Board
Kaberle or Ehrhoff.
Kaberle has the plus side of playing a ton. He plays PP, SH, everything. He's get you a guaranteed 40-50 pts. Also, the chances of Kaberle being moved this season to a contender is very high. His value will sky rocket when he is moved from the offensively challenged Leafs.
Ehrhoff's is fortunate to be playing on a team in SJ that seems to be scoring much more this year than in years past. Setogucho and Pavelski's contributions have helped propel this team's overall offensive value. Ehrhoff is getting secondary PP unit time and good overall minutes.
Toss up between the two I think. I would stay away from the inconsistent Bergeron, who despite playing on a defensively sound team, still can't play defense to save his life.
My pick: Kaberle
Kaberle is probably your best option even though he is with the leafs. Ehrhoff has been terrible as of late with 0 pts in his last 10 games. Bergeron has been hot lately but to give something up for him would be risky considering he is not an overly offensive defenseman and he plays for the Wild.