• Who to Start Message Board

  • BV BV Mar 1, 2013 3:12 PM Flag

    Malkin Trade. Please Advise

    I've been having no luck this year with IR from Spezza to Karlson, Malkin, Brodeur ect. so I'm in need of some kind of hockey miracle to pull something out.

    With Brodeur being on IR right now, I only have one goalie. Last night I quickly picked up both O'Reilly and Kadri and I had someone offer for them right away.

    The offer was

    He gives: Jeff Carter, Logan Couture, and Ray Emery

    I give: Evgeni Malkin, Ryan O'Reilly, and Nazem Kadri

    Even though Malkin is on IR, I don't know for how long and I feel like he's offering me Emery as bate because I'm in desperate need of a goalie. He also has Rinne, Scrivens, and Schneider for goalies. Would it be too much to ask for Rinne over Emery?

    Thoughts? Thank you!

    H2H league 7F - 3D - 2G - 4BN - 2IR
    G / A / +- / PIM / PPP / SHP / SOG / HIT / BLK / W / GGA / SV / SV% / SHO

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • No Dice. Emery is good spot duty but Crawford is not seriously injured... if your trading Malkin, you need bona fide starter coming back. Also. Kadri will have same or better season as both Carter and Couture. At least not less enough to justify dealing Malkin. Obviously the problem is not knowing Malkin update but I bet he is back sooner than later and will rack for you then.