• Who to Start Message Board

  • Kurt Kurt Jan 26, 2013 4:04 PM Flag

    Think this is a good trade?

    I've been offered Malkin, Boyle, Plekanec, and Bryzgalov for my Backstrom (C), James Neal, Matt Carle, and Pekka Rinne.
    Malkin and Bryz are shaky so far, but so is Backstrom and Rinne... but I really like Neal... but I'd really like Boyle too. What would you do??

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • I would reject his trade

      malkin/ Boyle would be upgrade for Back/Carle but a downgrade for Bryz/Neal

      With your 3 tenders yu are set to be #1 or 2 in goalie stats Neal is a stud sniper and can not be replaced by Malkin.

      Remember Malky's ice time will be cut back from last year with Syd back this year. Malky vs Neal PPP's should be very close

      i would take Neal/Back over Malky/Plec most days

    • Not enough info to evaluate properly.

      Post league settings and your roster

      Glad to help

      • 2 Replies to David f
      • Rotisserie

        G
        A
        +/-
        PIM
        PPP
        SOG

        Mike Richards
        (LA - C,LW)
        Jordan Staal
        (Car - C,LW)
        James Neal
        (Pit - LW,RW)
        Shane Doan
        (Pho - LW,RW)
        Vladimir Tarasenko
        (StL - RW)
        Jeff Carter
        (LA - C,RW)
        Andrei Markov
        (Mon - D)
        Kevin Bieksa
        (Van - D)
        Matt Carle
        (TB - D)
        Joni Pitkanen
        (Car - D)
        BN
        Patrick Kane
        (Chi - C,RW)
        BN
        Nicklas Backstrom
        (Was - C)
        BN
        Bobby Ryan
        (Anh - LW)
        IR
        Brent Burns
        (SJ - D)IR

        W
        GAA
        SV*
        SA*
        SV%
        SHO

        Antti Niemi
        (SJ - G)
        Pekka Rinne
        (Nsh - G)
        BN
        Niklas Backstrom
        (Min - G)

      • Depends on your point system - but I wouldn't typically make a 4 player trade

        Plekanec value will rise a bit - with Pacioretty out 3-4 weeks.....but I am a bit biased and have a Plekanec jersey

        Go Habs!!

 

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football