Who to Start Message Board
ok this guy offered me this trade i would be losing Malkin, iginla, Gabroik and cammalleri but I would be getting Crosby, St. Louis, Savard, and Bobby Ryan i don't think I will not accept it but i would still like people say what they think
Once you have Malkin and Iggy on your line up... don't even think of trading them.
Compare to the other side, u gonna finnish the year up rank facing his team.. that's for sure.
That's the reason why the other guy wanna trade... your better !
let's look at it this way: Crosby seems to be a bit injury prone so you should keep Malkin; as for Iginla or St.Louis, that one's pretty even so is Cammalleri and Ryan.. lookin at Savard or Gaborik I'd probably take Savard only b/c he's rarely hurt at all.. it's really a toss up b/c Gaborik is so untrustworthy..you might want to consider keeping Malkin and proposing a trade with the other 6 guys..
no good can come out of this trade. Holding on to Gaborik is a risk but you'd be losing Iginla and he's going to have a great year. He'll be back to scoring chances with Cammalleri gone.
Plus Malkin is always healthy and Crosby tends to miss 5-10 games a year lately.
Also, Boston is not going to have the same season. I think Savard (who started off really strong last year) will tend towards the 80 pts barrier instead of 88 (close to 90) like last year.
Malkin > Crosby
Iginla > Savard
Cammalleri < St Louis (always gets 80+ pts)
Gaborik < Ryan (this year will be a great full year)
Malkin > or = Crosby
Iginla > St. Louis
Gaborik <<< Savard
Cammalleri > or = Ryan
So, the answer is no. But, you do what the other guys said and trade Gaborik for a used tampon because the tampon is less of a pussy.
- 3 Replies to Brock W
Hope you're being sarcastic because when healthy, Gaborik is a top 20 forward. (could outscore savard easily, savard has him beat in assists though, one of the leagues most elite playmakers. Goals are worth more than assists in 99% of leagues.)
He's a huge risk because he's made of paper and glass instead of skin and bones.
I'd trade him for any of St.Louis, Savard or Ryan for sure, just because I like playing it on the safe side. Gaborik could have a huge season and is surely worth more than a 'used tampon'.
Overall I would do the trade but I agree with the 2 posters before me.
Try to see if he'll take Gab+Cam for Savard+Ryan. (You win that by a mile.)
If he doesn't take it, offer him Gaborik for Ryan.
If he doesn't take either of those, do this trade.
Personally, I don't trust Gaborik to stay healthy, I think Cammalleri will have a slower year.
On the other side, Bobby Ryan could explode this year, StLouis and Savard are PPG guys and Crosby is Crosby.
I would take it.
Expert Fantasy Advice
Every major league team's bullpen hierarchy, all in one place. … More »
Predicting all things American League in 2015. … More »
While Scott Pianowski is an agnostic drafter for fantasy baseball, some March targets were recurring. … More »
If you're thinking about test-driving daily for the first time, read on. We're here for you. … More »
Many drafts, many common-link batters for Pianow. Michael Brantley leads things off. … More »