It's a longterm dynasty league where you can sign players long term at a 5 dollar increase each year over 5 years. Both players are valued at 10 dollars for this year if I keep them. I can also option them for 10 dollars for one year.
My keepers so far are:
I can't make up my mind on Dickey or Chapman. I don't think Dickey can do it past the 3 year contract. So I don't wanna lock him up 5 years. But he is more of a sure thing. Chapman is unproven but could be a top 10 starter. He has huge future upside.
I have both of them also and I am only considering Chapman. If he flops as a starter he will suceed as a closer again. Dickey wont have the advantage of pitching to the pitcher this year. With the DH he won't have a soft spot in the lineups facing him. It's Chapman for me.