• General Message Board

  • ryno ryno Jan 23, 2013 12:07 AM Flag

    david wright or ryan zimmerman???

    Im in a keeper league and i have both. An owner wants wright from me but i want to know who would you rather have and why. Thanks was thinking of doing wright, matt cain, and texiera for reyes, matt moore and either cargo or elsburry..

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • Simple offer Wright for Cargo end of trade. Zimmerman for Ellsbury end of the trade. To get Moore,Reyes and Cargo would be epic!
      As to your difference in Wright/Zimmerman. Wright is just a tick better in numbers projected wise. Zimmerman does have the more potent lineup around him and if you take away his first 2months last season he would likely be a top 2 round pick. I'd be happy rolling with either of them. Now, you can make that owner think you Wright is a better value by making that offer I suggested. Sending Wright if Cargo is in the trade. Or sending Zimmerman if Ellsbury is in the trade. Cuz honestly Cargo is a tick above Ellsbury. And in injury risks Cargo is like Wright whereas Ellsbury is worse than Zimmerman but Zimmerman is worse than Wright.
      When it comes to keeper value, I'm way up on Moore over Cain Reyes on Texiera. Moore will be top 10 pitcher in Baseball either by season's end or by end of next season.
      Your whole trade is a win acquiring Moore and losing Texiera

    • Wright is better but I think Zimmerman will have a bounce back year I'd still take wright .