I'm in similar, tricky situation. Right now I'm down 4-6. Down by .06 in ERA, down by 1 HR, down by 2 RBI. Just need to tie him in any of these categories as I hold the tiebreak. Think I'm going to sit Morrow and start Homer Bailey.
For you, I'd probably sit your pitchers. He'd have to get under 1 whip for combined pitchers rest of night to win it...probably.