I just dropped Maybin for Dirks. I have a similar problem with Hosmer, as you with Pujols, but I have Dunn and Butler. Tough call, is Dirks the real deal? The answer to your question lies in your league. Are other managers savvy enough to pick up Goldshmidt and stash him? The bigger question is whether you need Dirks in your OF? If you need him, you don't have much choice, but as a BN I'd probably stick with Goldshmidt, there is more talent there.