General Message Board
-
Werth/Cain or McCutchen/Carpenter?
Which is the better end of this deal?
Werth/Cain
McCutchen/Carpenter?
Team with McCutchen Carpenter needs a serious boost in power and is the league leader in SB by far, and will continue to be so without McCutchen.
Team with Werth Cain is in desperate need of SB, and already has the best pitching in the league.
Is this a good deal or is either side getting ripped off?-
These guys that say one side is soooo much better than the other are out of their minds. This is a very fair and even trade.
- 1 Reply to Kendall
-
No that isn't fair. The pitcher and hitter are better on the cutch/carp side.
-
Carpenter side easily. The guy is one of the top pitchers, especially for fantasy and McCutchen is no slouch.
- 1 Reply to Shawn M
-
Not close. Carpenter is a proven ace on one of the top teams in the NL. McC is a more complete and reliable player than Werth, who no longer steals bases and whose HRs are down.
Werth/ Cain are fine players, Carp/McC are better.
-
good deal, like the mccutchen carpenter side better personally
-
its a good deal
-