General Message Board

depends on league format for the best answer, but Id prefer CC and Hamilton. Lincecum is a slightly better long keeper, but CC is in his prime and pitching with a great offense. He is the safer choice, and with your 3 1st round level guys, you want the safer starter.

All that said, if you can make some trades, do it. Lincecum and Hamilton for Hanley? Hamilton and Lee for Braun?

CC & tim. i don't keep hamilton based on one good year. you have to keep tim for sure in a keeper league. he is a lot younger than the rest. i think holliday is a safer bet than hamilton instead of CC if you want another hitter but don't let lincy get away.

Hamilton and Holliday, easy choices.

i'd go hamilton and lincecum, somebody to anchor your rotation. what league is this, a 6 team league, a 4 team league? this sounds really shallow.

anyone else curious as to how he has Pujols and Wright aswell as these options for keepers? Either it's a 4 team league or it's a league of panda bears. Panda bears don't draft well...

Lincecum and Hamilton, unless other guys are keeping the top SP's. If they are I would keep Lincecum and C.C. You can't stream and get the same results as top tier pitchers.

lincecum and hamilton.

Sabithia because when he starts to pitch for the yankees he will do a great job.

c.c. and lincecum. if you already have 2 hitters your keeping, keep 2 of the best pitchers in your league and really kill the rest of the field. hope this helped.

Lincecum and Lee, no-brainer.