General Message Board

my rebuttal was that they can't retrace every game and say "Oh, well in the 5th inning of this game on 7/22, So-and-So hit a game-tying home run".

If he stays consistant, he should. But if he keeps having his bad days, he won't. I know he doesn't lead the AL in HR, but he is in RBIs and he is a great fielder and baserunner. If he doesn't, it'll be between Quentin and maybe Kinsler

There's no rebuttal there... So you think Hamilton should be this year's AL MVP???

I understand! I gave my rebuttal to the same statement you made in the other post

Again, I'm well aware that voters are not required to vote for guys on contending teams, I'm simply saying that it SHOULD be a HUGE factor in the final decision...

That's the first one I could think of! I'm pretty sure that there are more!

2003- A-Rod, the Rangers didn't make the playoffs and not above .500

Among others

I mean, I can understand why you say it should, but it doesn't. They can't retrace every game and say "Oh, well in the 5th inning of this game on 7/22, So-and-So hit a game-tying home run".

21 years ago??? are you kidding???

How am I a moron? It's really how they vote! I don't understand why yall are saying this!

Well Said!