General Message Board
I would agree with you on general terms.
Depending on your team's needs, the better person might vary.
Once Doumit comes back, I think he will hit for a higher average. Francoeur will typically hit for a lower average, because he is such a free-swinger.
But, if the Braves lineup continues to hit the ball well(and Teixeira wakes up from his slumber) Francoeur has the potential to be in more RBI potential AB.
I do not think there is a clear-cut answer here.
Analyze your team's needs(catcher, Avg, RBI, HR, XBH, etc.)
Make your decision from there...