Draft and Trade Talk Message Board
List your entire roster.
Also...let us know your total number of keepers.
Number of teams in your league and style of play (H2H or roto) would be helpful too.
Either your league only allows 3 keepers or less or you erred in your selection of keepers.
Assuming both are healthy, I would go with Wright easily. A shallower position and excels at the almost same rate Craig does in Craig's best cats. He can steal bases and hit home runs. This is a no brainer to me.