• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Rich Rich Jul 3, 2013 7:11 AM Flag

    Trade Offer in 12 Keeper League

    I was just offered the following in a 10 team, 12 keeper Roto. Somehow the person that offered me this trade insists that I win as all 4 players offered to me are keepers. I have to laugh at this offer.

    I get (Brett Gardner , Chase Headley, Hunter Pence, CC Sabathia)
    David Ortiz, Jacoby Ellsbury, Carlos Beltrán

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • For 2013 that's a horrible deal for you obviously. I don't like it much better in 2014.

    • That's not a bad deal, the one thing you are losing is ellsbury. Ortiz and beltran are good but old and wont last much longer, you wouldn't keep them in a keeper league most likely so they will be up for grabs. You probably, depending on what kind of prospects you have on your team, wouldn't keep gardner, headley either. Maybe Pence, he is quality. If you have plenty of SB and need pitching, this is a good deal, if ou have some scrub to drop. maybe counter for someone you like better than headly and offer him another guy so its 4 for 4. IMO.

      • 1 Reply to zgmike
      • zgmike, It is a 12 keeper league. I would certainly keep Beltran and Ortiz next year. Look at the last two years of production from them. They may be old, but they hit for average and HR/RBI/Runs. They easily have one more year in them and their trade value is much higher than what was offered. I am in last place. A top 4-5 team may want to make a deal with me within the next 6-8 weeks to win it all. I am still get emails from him about this trade :-)


Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football