Puig's BABIP is close to .500. That won't fly for long. McCutcheon should improve but has fallen off from a phenomenal 1st half in 2012 (over 1.000 OPS). He may be at a new lower level now. Tough call. McCutcheon is young enough to turn in a 2nd half like last year's first half. So it's McCutcheon in a split decision.