• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • lulias lulias Jun 19, 2013 8:48 PM Flag

    Trade Help...Should I do this trade?

    Someone in my keeper league offered me

    Buster Posey - Drafted in 6th round
    Justin Upton - Drafted in 11 round
    Ben Zobrist

    for

    Jean Segura - Drafted in 20th round
    Matt Wieters
    Adam Dunn

    Is this a good trade for me? Im currently in 8th out of 12. Not out of the race yet. I love Segura and his awesome keeper value. Any advice greatly appreciated

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • omg and you getting posey?? i would do it ASAP!!!

    • You'd be upgrading at every position with those 3, I'd do it in a second.

    • Do their draft rounds matter in your keeper, in terms of next year? I know there are leagues like that but I have no experience with that. We just keep eight players regardless of where they were drafted.

      Anyway, it looks like an upgrade at catcher and, despite recent struggles for J Upton, a big upgrade at OF/UTIL. The price being you give up Segura (young and on the rise) for Zobrist (useful w/great OBP skills, but declining). That's a tough one...
      I don't think I would do it in my league, simply because I don't think the catching upgrade is big enough and there's always a lot of injury risk at C. If your league's draft does reward value I think it would be even more the case. Segura in 20th round is easily the best value.

 

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football