A gets: Cole Hamels, Jimmy Rollins, Ernesto Frieri
B gets: Anibal Sanchez, Chase Headley, Kenley Jansen
I'd consider that farily even. Hamels Sanchez. Rollins = Headley. Jansen Feire if Mattingly actually gives him the closing gig and it sticks. So it's a wash and just depends on whether you need a SS or a 3B.