• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Dingy Dingy Mar 27, 2013 11:43 PM Flag

    Big Trade Need your help

    I just got offered a trade and need some advice. I give up Kemp, A Gordon, J Rollins, J Papelbon, and H. Kendrick and I get Posey, A Simmons, B Parnell, J. Kipnis and A. Craig. I feel I am getting the short end of the stick here but any help would be appreciated.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • I wouldn't do that deal since I think the Kemp side gives up too much:
      -You'd have 2 catchers in what I assume is a one catcher league and Kemp is more valuable than Posey being a top 5 player overall - while Posey is overrated.
      -Craig would be an upgrade over Gordon - but there is some injury concern there.
      -Papelborn is a top 3 closer this year while Parnell is a very uncertain card.
      -Simmons is an unknown at SS - an exciting young player, but unproven -.and with Rollins you get a veteran with a decent floor although you might also get some injury concerns.
      -Kipnis is an upgrade over Kendrick but then again Kendrick seems poised to bounce back while Kipnis might be due for some regression.

 

Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football