• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • Matt J Matt J Feb 5, 2013 12:37 PM Flag

    Who to Keep??

    12 team, H2H standard scoring. Keeping one of these three.
    Round available to keep determined by last yrs draft round.
    Pick one, C.Sale 10th rd, Trumbo 14th round, Victor Martinez 18th round.
    Thanks

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • While I'm not high on Trumbo, his upside for a 14th rd pick is a surefire keeper. If I were drafting him I wouldn't take him til after the 8th round. Sale being a 10th rd pick, somebody must have seen his value for 2012. I think Sale is a 7-10th rd pick. So you're not gaining many picks by keeping him and a better pitcher just may be there anyway.
      Martinez. It's not that I'm not a fan its just that there are many special Catchers out there now in Perez,Rosario,Lucroy with Zunino and TDArnaud approaching Bigs. You can probably draft him again late. Though if this were a 2C league I'd then keep him.

    • It would have to be Trumbo in the 14th round. I love V-Mart but his age and recovery prove too uncertain. Sale is due for major regression. He had the biggest innings jump of any pitcher in 10 years and is built like Randy Johnson after surviving the Holocaust