• Draft and Trade Talk Message Board

  • DL2014 DL2014 Feb 4, 2013 9:47 PM Flag

    ??Can You Answer This??

    $$ 10 Team H2H, Standard 5x5 + OBP & QS

    KEEPING 5 (rd 1-5)

    Which 5? ..and why?

    J Bruce
    J Zimmerman

    ..and why? :)

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • pedroia, castro, beltre, zimmerman, bruce - as a keeper league that only keeps a handful of guys, I would leave the pitchers alone as Gio is the only true keeper and he's staring at a 50 game suspension if found in violation of PED-use. I am also not a Bautista believer at all... his career avg hovers in the .250s, he's coming off injury, the MLB has instituted stricter testing including HGH, and I simply don't buy into his talent, therefor I would keep the younger Jay Bruce whose power appears more legit with less question marks. Finally, I know Beltre is old and Zimmerman is overrated, but they both start at 3B, which is a desert for for solid productivity. I'd keep them both and then consider dealing one or the other for an additional piece you might desire. Pedroia and Castro are no-brainers.

    • Bautista,Beltre,Castro,Pedroia. After those 4 no others would/should be Keepers in a 10team league. Gio just may get Suspended for that whole Miami article.
      Bruce is your best Keeper at 5 its just I don't feel hes a top 50 player. Zimmerman will be a QS beast but he's a genuine 3.1ERA guy with 6-7ip 2/3ER outings. Not a high K guy. And those 3ER starts lead to many No Decisions. Yovani. No. he just cant pitch more than 7ip with high pitch counts.
      Scherzer is like Zimmerman only a 2-4ER outing guy with Ks. That means NDs and no QS. I like him I just don't think that he's Keeper worthy in a 10 team league. He'll probably last in to the 3rd/4thrds on redraft. And Konerko is one I think lasts in to the 6/7th round on redraft. You can get a Jesus Montero,Napoli type to play either C/1b with an eye on TDA/Zunino for Catcher if you cant pick up a decent one.

    • Bautista, Pedroia, Beltre, Bruce, Castro

    • Only a mere 5 keepers there will be TONS of pitchers in re-draft so I'd probably keep Konerko along with your first four listed. You got your entire starting infield and a good start to your outfield all set. You are golden.

      KennyPowers is right about the pitching. If it isn't one of those 3 pitchers or maybe David Price, don't keep them. Not with only 5 keepers. Position players are the core to any team in my book. Build around those. I just like Konerko more than Bruce cause I think other owners will hold on to their slugging 1B too and that there will be more OF available. But either would do.

    • Sub in Bruce formGio and you're set. So much pitching no need to keep any unless its veer lander, Keyshawn, or maybe Strasburg... You take care of hitting first


Expert Fantasy Advice

Sign up for Yahoo Fantasy Football